| Author |
Replies: 19 / Views: 3,487 |
|
Valued Member
United States
60 Posts |
Hey guys, told you about the 3AJ I found in a E-bay lot... Makes me wonder if the lot I received wasn't some experienced collectors pile of oddities? Any info you could give me on the following is appreciated! Have they been attributed? Are they worth above spot silver? I've done a lot of searching but no dice!
|
|
|
|
Valued Member
 United States
60 Posts |
First one has a slight die scratch or is that a crack? Looks to straight to be a crack? 
|
|
Valued Member
 United States
60 Posts |
I heard these called flow marks, but to me they appear to be die trails... Any input on either of these coins appreciated! 
|
|
Valued Member
 United States
60 Posts |
LoL, Super Dave, Where are you?!! LOL! Thanks forum!
|
|
Moderator
 United States
23522 Posts |
Die cracks mean very little with Morgans, most especially 1921's. They're assumed, rather than excepted; you'll have a harder time finding a 1921 without die cracks rather than one with them. Mind them; record them; they will help build the case for whatever variety you finally determine the coin to be.
What you're calling "die trails," however, are much more interesting. Seriously-worn Morgan dies tend to show these lines. 1921-S is the poster child for these wear marks. The coin you present in the last post, though, is simply over the top. I've never seen such a degree of "trailing" (as opposed to "die trails," which are still, IMO, a theoretical study).
The trouble I see is, some of them look like they are more "instead of," rather than "in addition to" the known design of the die. You'll understand that everything you see as "raised" on a coin is "recessed" on a die, so wear will only add to what you see as "raised" on a coin. What I see on your coin (particularly "RIB", especially the "I") doesn't fit the pattern.
It's way too early to come to conclusions. I'd sure like to see full-face images of the whole coin. Look at an undamaged Morgan, see where the serifs exist, and you'll see what I'm saying.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 United States
1551 Posts |
Just looking at what little there is in the photos ...My first thought was Counterfeit. I very well may be wrong but a full view of both sides would be nice!
|
|
Valued Member
 United States
60 Posts |
I don't believe them to be Counterfeit...?... There is a great degree of wear on the coin that I pictured which as Dave explained may exagerate the condition.
The nearest I could find anywhere on the internet was a 1921-S "melted date"...
If anybody could post a link to 1921-S exhibiting die trail like pictured, I'd be very grateful! I'm interested in the variety that Dave mentioned!
I'll be posting "full coin pictures" after batteries charge for a few. You guys would be cracking up... I've got a 1990's camera that I'm using to picture my coins through a desk-top magnifier! LOL!
I've got two coins in question w/die trails... Does anybody know how many pictures photo bucket will hold? I don't want my other pictures removed because they might help somebody...
|
|
Pillar of the Community
3660 Posts |
Die trails, trailing, die wear, what ever a person might call it.... doesn't look like that.... COUNTERFEIT.
|
|
Valued Member
 United States
60 Posts |
Alright, got lucky and found batteries! Here is the coin pictured last night with the trails. Specimen one LOL!  Notice what appears to be a clash mark above the motto highlighted by soft led pencil 
|
|
Valued Member
 United States
60 Posts |
Here is specimen two!! LOL! I feel like we are Doctors talking! Please not the trails are not as pronounced and no mark above motto on the reverse. This coin was not pictured yet!  
|
|
Valued Member
 United States
60 Posts |
I might seem like I know what I'm talking about, don't let me fool you guys tho. This is only what I've learned in the past few years and I greatly appreciate your time and help... After all, where else would I go with these? I'm one smarter to know also, it's input from people like us that advance our hobby! Not to mention I almost turnned in that 3JA for scrap value on accident because I'm hard up right now.... Hope I find some others in the older Morgans I've got!!
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 United States
1551 Posts |
It looks real from here, The die is not sunken and it still had or has a lot of detail. The denticles do look shallow, I was under the understanding the comes from polishing.
|
|
Valued Member
United States
104 Posts |
I have Morgans with those lines, except mine are more like a scribble. I also have one with a weird cutlike line from almost the tip of one wing straigt to his, well, crotch. It's so deep mid-wing it makes a shadow in the light at certain angles.
|
|
Valued Member
 United States
60 Posts |
So, I'm confused here? Is there any verdict as to an attribution? Does zeewool still think these are fakes? They seem to be made of real silver! Who would have faked a coin back then, out of real silver? Weights are dead nuts against others at 26.8 grams. I was hoping there was a VAM for these conditions? I will certainly take Dave's advice and salt them away!
|
|
Pillar of the Community
3660 Posts |
Quote: Does zeewool still think these are fakes? No, after seeing the entire coin photos, they look real enough to me.... I am very often fooled by online photos, especially closeups of only certain areas..... die wear to the periphery generally shows many little lines trailing from the letters to the coin edge rather than what had appeared to me to be just a warping of the letter tops.... I believe that they are genuine, but as for attribution, nearly any good die could reach this state..... 1921 Morgans are extremely difficult for most people to identify as far as vams.... your best bet would be SperDave.... (if anyone could do it), it would be him.
|
|
Valued Member
 United States
60 Posts |
Thanks so much zeewool! I learned something here! I always thought that trails were caused by cleaning or the way the die was intially cut? I am a machinist/cnc operator by trade. "OldFlabbergeezer" is just a way to bust stones, I'm 40 tho and not far away with how fast this went by!
Iappreciate the input, the forum won't let me private message him tho. I don't know why?
|
| |
Replies: 19 / Views: 3,487 |