Your Opinion - Toned Versus Clean

That's a tough one. #4 is out, in my opinion. I guess I'll go with #3. I like a little toning but I like white as well. So I guess #3 is in the middle! I love the designs of all those classic commemoratives!

For me, a fan of brilliant coins, it would be:

#2, #1,,,,,,,#3,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,#4

The brilliant coin (#2) is the most appealing, the colors on #1 appear to be outstanding in terms of eye appeal, #3 appears to be above average in eye appeal and a reasonable compromise. #4, however, completely lacks eye appeal for me - so much so, in fact, that I can't see me ever wanting to pay money for it.

2,3,1 then 4.

2-3-1-4
John1

me too

3 most, then 2

I love radial toning, but prefer the colors not start dipping into the designs. I wouldn't buy 1 or 4

2-3-1----
----
----
----4

#4 is my last choice.
#1 is likely darker in-hand so next to last (unless it appears as imaged then it's second choice).
#3 is second choice (or third per comments above).
#2 would likely be my top choice but remember I am not a huge fan of toning.